Showing posts with label immigration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label immigration. Show all posts

Thursday, March 2, 2017

Economics of Immigration #3

Supporting the author’s view that immigration has very specific causes and effects, on pages 162-7 of We Wanted Workers he relates a story about Russian mathematicians.

For decades prior to the collapse of the USSR there was little contact between mathematicians in Russia and those in Western countries. The most popular Soviet research field was differential equations, accounting for 18% of all publications. The most popular American fields were statistics and operations research, accounting for 16% of all publications. After the USSR collapsed many Russian mathematician migrated to the USA in the 1990's. Data collected by the American Mathematical Society showed a sharp increase in the unemployment rate of newly minted mathematicians and identified recent immigrants as a leading cause. The author and another person looked further. They looked at the effect the “supply shock” the Russian mathematicians had on two different groups of American mathematicians – those who specialized in differential equations and those who specialized in statistics. The number of papers published by American mathematicians in differential equations dropped sharply, while those published in statistics dropped only slightly. They concluded that the entry of the exceptional Russian mathematicians crowded out newly minted mathematicians and non-tenured faculty, especially in differential equations. The latter group moved to lower-ranked institutions (with higher teaching loads) or even outside academia, which reduced their opportunities to do research. 

While the author mentions “quants” on Wall Street, he did not speculate that the effects may have been different if the collapse of the Soviet Union had instead occurred about 10 years earlier. In the 1980’s there was a large wave of mathematicians and physicists who moved into finance jobs, especially for investment firms and big banks. They were hired to a great extent because they could solve differential equations that were needed to theoretically price financial options. The solving was far more by a numerical method (finite difference, lattice, Monte Carlo) using a computer – software needed developed – in contrast to closed form solutions (which the Black-Scholes formula is) with pencil and paper. I can only speculate about a lesser “supply shock” on American mathematicians specializing in differential equations if the Russian influx had occurred about 1980. The unemployment spike probably would have been much smaller. The effect on the number of research papers may have been less.

Monday, February 27, 2017

Economics of Immigration #2

Statistics can be used to support different political opinions regarding immigration. One study might claim immigrants use welfare more and impose a fiscal burden on natives, while another study denies this. Page 177 of We Wanted Workers illustrates both perspectives. It shows two graphs of Trends in Welfare Use 1994-2015. Each graph has two lines – one for immigrants and one for natives, all significantly sloping upward after year 2000 or so. The Y-axis is percent receiving assistance. The first graph shows a large and widening difference between the lines, immigrants higher than natives. The second graph shows the lines for the two groups very close together. The numbers were derived from the same database, so why the difference? It is that #1 is based on number of households and #2 is based on number of persons.

Consider a young, single woman who immigrates to the USA and then becomes a single mother with two children and qualifies for public assistance. For #1 the household is counted once. The contribution to the Y value is 1 to the numerator and 1 to the denominator. For #2 the family counts for three persons – the mother as one immigrant and the children as two natives. The contribution to the value of Y for natives is 2 to the numerator and 2 to the denominator. Obviously such counting increases the overall value of Y for natives, enough overall to make little difference between immigrants and natives. 

Clearly a US citizen who favors open immigration would tend to choose #2 as evidence to support his/her opinion, and one who favors strict immigration controls would tend to choose #1 as evidence to support his/her opinion. 

Household statistics seem more objective. Adults earn most income, obtain public assistance, and pay the bills, not children.

Saturday, February 25, 2017

Economics of Immigration #1

We Wanted Workers is the title of a book about the economics of immigration. (There is little or nothing about refugees, crime, and terrorism.) The author is a Harvard University economist who has studied immigration for 30+ years. I read some of Thomas Sowell’s book many years ago, but it’s the only book I’ve read about immigration recently. That and immigration becoming a hot political issue prompted me to read it.

There are crucial differences between viewing immigrants as workers, and more broadly, as people. The things that immigrants experience are specific to time and place, the people involved, and the people affected, that it is easy to overgeneralize. One should be skeptical about “expert” opinion, especially when tied to a political opinion. 

The author lists several of his insights. 
- Those who choose to move to the USA are fundamentally different from those who stay behind. 
- Assimilation is not inevitable, and it may take decades. 
- Immigrants affect the job opportunities of natives via supply and demand. Data suggest a 10% increase in the number of workers in a skill group probably lowers the average wage of the group about 3%. 
- Immigrants in the workforce redistributes wealth from those who compete with them to those who use immigrants. 
- The welfare state makes it possible that gains from the employment of immigrants are offset by assistance payments if the immigrants are net users of social assistance programs. There is little doubt that immigrants receive more assistance than natives in the short-run, but this may reverse in the long-run. 
- The argument that models and data can determine public policy scientifically ignores the advocate’s motives. 
- Low-skill, low income immigrants have much different effects than high-skilled, high income ones. The former make use of public assistance; the latter do not. The latter pay higher than average taxes; the former lower than average taxes or none.
- The more one aggregates skill groups, the more one masks the effects on more specific skill groups. 

The ideology of open borders can be held by libertarians and many on the leftist political spectrum, for different motives. 

He contrasts native and immigrant a lot. They are not completely mutually exclusive in common usage. Native sometimes means somebody living in a particular place for a long time even if foreign-born. Also, an infant born shortly before his immigrant parents arrive in the USA does not differ in many other ways than one who was born in the USA shortly after his parents arrive. So it seems anomalous to call the first an immigrant and the second a native. On the other hand, such anomalies may not be statistically significant.